How Can We Say An Animal Is Better Off Dead
Animal Ethics,  GUEST POSTS

How Can We Say An Animal Is Better Off Dead?

How Can We Say An Animal Is Better Off Dead? Hello everyone, I hope you are well. In today’s post, I will be sharing a guest post from Dr Jacqui Wilmshurst. She is a speaker at the Annual Oxford Animal Ethics Summer School and founder of Nala’s Nook Squirrel & Corvid Sanctuary. Dr Jacqui Wilmshurst will share her own experiences of rescuing and grappling with this question. She will do so through the lens of her own disabilities. It’s estimated that over a quarter of a million animals are rescued each year in the UK. These animals are often saved from horrific situations, suffering massive physical and mental trauma. Once rescued, can these animals live a good life? Or would they actually be better off dead? This is a question those involved in animal rescue often ask and get asked.

How Can We Say An Animal Is Better Off Dead?

I hold a licence from Natural England, to keep grey squirrels in captivity “for welfare purposes”. These licences came into effect in December 2019. This was after the previous licences enabling holders to release them back into the wild were revoked for conservation reasons. The wording on the licence, of keeping them captive “for welfare purposes”, implies that having a life in captivity is better for them. It is considered better than the only alternative of having them killed via euthanasia.

Meanwhile, all other guidance for wildlife rehabilitators in Britain is explicit. It states that no wild animal should be kept in permanent captivity. This, therefore, puts any owner of a licensed sanctuary for wild animals in a difficult position. They are caught between keeping animals permanently captive who cannot legally be returned to the wild as a preferable alternative to death. This happens while also being told that it is not acceptable to do so. In deciding between the two, we are forced to weigh up their right to life against their right to death. We must somehow work out what is best on their behalf.

Bella’s Story

A young grey squirrel (about 12 weeks old) was being kicked around in a city park by a group of boys. A man passing by saw and intervened. He scooped her up and drove to the closest rescue centre, who brought her to me as the only sanctuary in the area equipped to take her in.

I rushed her straight to the vet, who confirmed my initial fears. She had suffered a spinal injury and was unlikely to regain full use of her back legs. I had to decide whether to provide her an opportunity for rehabilitation, for a life of permanent captivity, or have her ‘put to sleep’.

Would she be better off dead because she’s a member of an invasive non-native species? Would she be better off dead because she can’t return to the wild?  And would she be better off dead because she’s physically disabled? Can a disabled, wild born, wild animal ever have quality of life in permanent captivity?

Conventional scientific opinion tells us that we can’t effectively ask animals what they want. At the same time, in the world of wildlife rehabilitation, there isn’t a universally agreed method. No standard exists to make decisions on whether an animal is better off alive or dead.

Not Today

Grey squirrels are enormously resilient animals. This is partly why they have been so successful at adapting to our ecosystems and habitats after being brought here from their native range in the eastern USA.  I have spent several years working with them, rearing them, and caring for them. I know how to spot a fierce will to live. When I was with this squirrel at the vet, that light was shining brightly in her eyes. This held true despite all that she had been through. So, following a lengthy discussion with the vet, the decision at that moment in time was simply: “Not today”.

We gave her the strongest available pain relief, and I took her home. I named her Bella.

Once home and settled in a secure cage with a heat pad and plenty of food and water, it was just the next day that I witnessed her using her still soft baby teeth to try with all her might to get through the shell of a hazelnut. Again, I thought, “not today”.

I left food for her, and put her medication into that, but largely left her alone. She rested most of the time but ate well. Her coat was shiny, and her eyes remained bright. “Not today”.

Help, on Her Terms

A few days later, she emerged from her pile of blankets and started climbing the bars. She was looking to explore and to engage with the world again. I moved her into a larger enclosure, and she climbed some more, using her body to the limit of its abilities. “Not today”.

Then she started to play, so I gave her some toys, and she played even more. “Not today”.

I noticed that she was pulling her head to one side, the way they do when they scratch with a back leg. This made me realise she needed some help. I used a toothbrush through the bars, and she attacked it repeatedly. Not because she was afraid, but because she had a good sense of her own boundaries and needs. “Not today”.

With perseverance, and a lot of broken toothbrushes, she eventually let me show her how good it was to have help with scratching. She started to seek out the toothbrush. “Not today”.

She is now three years old and currently thriving. Her life is still lived day by day. One day I could find myself having to say “yes, today”, if ever I feel that the evidence does not add up to a quality of life. But that choice will be hers and mine together.

Hard Choices

Not all animals who have come to my sanctuary have had the opportunity for a continued life. For some, when healing is not possible and long-term suffering is guaranteed, and when that bright light in the eyes has gone out, I have made the heartbreaking decision that they are now indeed better off dead.

While I continue to explore the options, for all the animals in my care, my choice is to value each life as an individual, simply because it’s theirs.

While I am not naïve about the problems in our wider ecosystems (and in fact work professionally as a conservation psychologist), I do not see grey squirrels as ‘pests’. Does that mean I consider those that live here to be ‘pets’? Absolutely not. They have a bite force of 7,000psi (look it up). They are not cuddly as adults, and they will destroy most things that they can reach with their teeth. They are very much wild animals, and they are not here to be my companions.

Instead, my enjoyment comes through the immense privilege of getting to know individuals personally and learning about their species through these relationships – what they need, what they are capable of, how they communicate. Also, what they teach me about myself as a human animal.

Not Better Off Dead

As a doctoral researcher at The Open University, I now explore these questions, and more, in great depth. Thankfully, an increasing number of researchers are doing the same, across a range of academic fields. They are doing so in relationship with many different species and contexts.

I work through a ‘care ethical’ lens. Instead of approaching these difficult decisions in a generalised, rational, and detached way, I approach them through my own relationship with the individual animal, the context, and the situation.  I absorb all that I can learn from the animal, while also recognising who I am. This includes being a licensed sanctuary owner with expertise and resources. Additionally, the relationship I have with each animal makes a difference in what choices I can make.

In their 2025 Kindness Index survey, the RSPCA revealed that 61% (up from 56% in 2024) of respondents think protecting wildlife should be the top priority for the RSPCA. Up to 60% (it varied by region) said they did not feel confident in knowing how to help if they found sick, injured or orphaned wildlife in need.

We can all make a contribution in our own way. This is mine. Working with both squirrels and birds who cannot return to the wild, I question what I do every day, and I don’t have most of the answers. What I do know is that being a member of a non-native species, being disabled, and being unable to return to the wild will never, at my sanctuary, be automatic criteria for being better off dead.

I hope you enjoyed that.

Talk soon.

 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

This topic was first presented by Dr Jacqui Wilmshurst at the Annual Oxford Animal Ethics Summer School. The Summer School is organised by the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics, an independent centre pioneering ethical perspectives on animals through academic research, teaching, and publication. The Centre comprises more than 100 academic Fellows worldwide. It also hosts the annual Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics Summer School, now in its tenth year. The Revd. Professor Andrew Linzey, Director of the Centre, is the subject of a new documentary called ‘The Animal Thing’.

 

Web: www.oxfordanimalethics.com/home

Web: www.theanimalthing.com

Instagram: @oxfordanimalethics

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@oxfordanimalethics

Life with Sonia is a personal growth and lifestyle blog empowering women with inspiration, practical advice, entrepreneurship insights, and a supportive community to develop and achieve confidence, resilience, and success in life.

10 Comments

  • jerry godinho

    I appreciate how you tackle such a difficult question head-on. It’s brave to explore whether there are situations where an animal might truly be “better off” dead, rather than just alive. You handle the complexity sensitively, showing care for animal welfare while still acknowledging the heartbreak and moral weight of letting go.

  • Barbie R

    The title definitely threw me for a loop because animals are full of love, and there is always room in our hearts for them. We don’t have to humanize them or keep them in our homes, but there are so many meaningful ways we can still show them love and care.

  • Melanie E

    This is such a powerful and heartfelt read. The way that Dr. Wilmshurst describes these difficult decisions with honesty, compassion, and respect for each animal’s life is truly inspiring. Bella’s journey especially touched me, proof that resilience and thoughtful care can really make all the difference.

  • LisaLisa

    Kudos to her, and a big “thank you” for all the work she’s doing to help our animals. I would’ve been furious to see kids kicking a squirrel, honestly, how can anyone be so cruel? Animals are God’s gifts to this world, and they deserve to live their lives peacefully in their natural habitat without people mistreating them. They’re not meant to be pets!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Shares